Just my personal opinion.
I like the managers and analysts at Sequoia. I think the two managers are excellent, and they have a team of excellent analysts.
They have an investor day every year, and the document that comes out of it is always very informative regarding the analysts and managers.
http://www.sequoiafund.com/Reports/Transcript13.pdfI think they are a highly experienced group of stock pickers, whom I trust. And very dedicated. With a storied tradition and history.
If I'm not mistaken, I believe that one of their analysts was or perhaps is seriously considered for the job to take over the main investing role at Berkshire Hathaway after Warren Buffett passes on. [In addition to the 2 former hedge fund managers that Berkshire Hathaway currently has].
Take a look at that Investor Day PDF referenced above. I'm extremely impressed with the depth of the analyst team, and how thoroughly they study the companies they invest in.
I own the fund both in a taxable account and an IRA.
I owned FAIRX for about 11 years. FAIRX is a one man show. It's the Bruce show. Night and day from SEQUX, which is a large team of analysts, each doing work and putting together the efforts in aggregate.
Berkowitz is obviously very smart and talented, but I gave up on him when I wasn't convinced my money was being managed with proper risk management.
When I saw over
50% in one stock [AIG, which is no longer over
50%, but still 42.8%], and generally the most concentrated stock portfolio of any stock mutual fund that I encountered, that concerned me. I was also concerned about Sears, St. Joe, Fannie and Freddie whose fate is in the hands of Congress.....a huge concentration in financials.....I lost my confidence in Berkowitz, and exited.
Also, I read a bunch of articles about Bruce Berkowitz, the sum total of which made me lack confidence in the person I was handing my money to, in FAIRX. Don't know if this is a super rock star mutual fund manager on an ego trip, but didn't want to take the risk, and I suspected it.
I was not making a forecast on the future performance of FAIRX, as that future performance will never be predictable. Warren Buffett suggested to 'keep your eyes on the players, not the scoreboard'. So although the scoreboard of FAIRX was good, I had my eyes on the player, and decided to make a sideways move to another fund.
Finally, although I do like the SEQUX team a lot, their performance over 1, 3 and
5 years is nothing to brag about.....although when I look at it by each calendar year, it looks better to me. Their YTD performance is awful, but who knows, this could be a great time to buy in........or maybe not.
I've been quite impressed by the benefits of just buying a stock index fund, where you don't have performance issues......you just get the market return minus the expenses [plus or minus a tiny tracking differential.] I like VTI and VTSAX.
Warren Buffett prefers a low cost S&P
500 index fund, like VFIAX, and has in his will that his wife's portfolio will be invested 90% in a low cost S&P
500 index fund, and 10% in short term government bonds
Any thoughts?