Have you lost confidence in FMIJX/FMIYX, S-T or L-T? Very valid points made by all. Maybe "hedge" was the wrong term and misused as BrianW points out.
I almost feel like adding to FMIJX now or waiting for it to pull-back further, could be trying to catch a "falling knife"; i'm just not sure and maybe way off.
NO DOUBT 13 months does not a trend make. But if significant under-performance continues for the next year or two and I have not, at least, consider another alternative, am i not doing myself a disservice? I'm not divesting from FMIJX, just reducing it from low-to-mid double-digits to just over 9%. I don't believe that's unreasonable, maybe i'm wrong though.
As BriansW says FOMO is maybe what is motivating me to branch out. The category is doing very well, but what will happen when the category goes south? Is FMIJX going to be the superhero as in the past? There are concerns as have been previously pointed out, asset bloat, weaker$, etc.
Lastly, I'm not saying 15.5% absolute return is bad; I would take it EVERY YEAR, but we all know that is a pipe dream. I guess my thoughts are if FMIJX continues to SIGNIFICANTLY under-perform the category, is it not worth a look-see and try to enhance performance while the getting is good?
Please let me know if I am off-base and/or missing the point! Thx!!!!
Have you lost confidence in FMIJX/FMIYX, S-T or L-T? FMIJX returned 15.5% in 2017. I'll take that every single time, thank you!
Know what you own and why you own it. FMIJX is exactly where one would expect it to be. If you are even looking at 2018 performance--which is to say around 12 trading days so far--you are better off indexing.
Have you lost confidence in FMIJX/FMIYX, S-T or L-T? 'mcmarasco', regarding hedging please remember that had you been invested in a Growth fund you would likely have to re-balance funds out, not in. Meaning you would likely add to the FMI fund, not reduce. 2018 may be another banner year, but are you making the classic mistake of buying high when you should allow FMI to pull back?
Have you lost confidence in FMIJX/FMIYX, S-T or L-T? PRESSmUP thank you for the read. They appear to be very pessimistic and cautious near-term which is ok, it's their job to do what they feel is best for the L-T, i get that.
I just hope that the SIGNIFICANT under-performance does not continue thru 2018 (and beyond). As you mentioned, the previous 3 years were outstanding, a reversal of that performance (i.e. 2017) would make that moot and FMIJX/FMIYX just another fund.
I do not think that will happen, but I am " hedging" and have reduced my investment to just over 9% and as slick mentioned (thx), I am dipping my toe into a growth oriented International fund.
Thanks everyone for your comments, please continue the conversation!!! Matt
Gundlach, Goldman Sound Warning On Emerging-Market Stock Rally Morgan Stanley the latest, saying that emerging equities may see a repeat of the year 2000, which began well and ended with a 32 percent drop.
I hope we do see a repeat of it. Because after that, from 200
1-2007, EM returned >20%/year.
Have you lost confidence in FMIJX/FMIYX, S-T or L-T? Appreciate the comments and insights! Thx!!
It's sometimes hard to accept SIGNIFICANT under performance. The 98th percentile in 2017 and early 2018 does not make a trend, but should it not raise "some" concern going forward???
Does it not warrant monitoring or am i being a little short-sighted and impatient?
Yes, they trailed badly in 20
17, but this was after a relative performance of 2nd, 8th and
1st in 20
14, 20
15 and 20
16 respectively. As Ben noted, their analysis of the ECB's actions are cautionary. I have sufficient irons in the fire to accept their caution at present. Attached is their most recent report...pls see starting on page 25.
http://www.fiduciarymgt.com/funds/shrpt/ann_shrpt_093017.pdf
Have you lost confidence in FMIJX/FMIYX, S-T or L-T? Appreciate the comments and insights! Thx!!
It's sometimes hard to accept SIGNIFICANT under performance. The 98th percentile in 2017 and early 2018 does not make a trend, but should it not raise "some" concern going forward???
Does it not warrant monitoring or am i being a little short-sighted and impatient?
Have you lost confidence in FMIJX/FMIYX, S-T or L-T? As with VMNFX, FMIJX is currency hedged. This has made a big difference in the past few years, as the dollar has gone from soaring in 20
16 to diving in 20
17.
If what you want is a smoother ride (i.e. one where currency is taken out of the equation), these were and are fine funds. If you want full exposure including currency volatility, buy something else.
Here's a chart showing these two funds against the foreign large blend average. While the two funds occasionally diverge (as would be expected, with one foreign one global), you can see how they take off relative to foreign large blend in 20
16, and then foreign large blend nearly catches up in the subsequent year.
Morningstar comparison chart.