High Yield Bond Funds mentioned have a bulge in 5-yr SDs. That is because they have full impact of pandemic 2020. The 3-yr window is just getting out of the main pandemic hit, and 10-yr reduces the pandemic impact as there are many non-pandemic years. That is why it is also useful to look at charts beyond summary statistics.
Another thing to note is that funds evaluated are of different types - ST-HY, IT-HY, multisector (that includes sovereigns + corporates + HYs + EMs), so they are expected to behave somewhat differently.
HY indexed ETFs are HYG, USHY, JNK, etc.
SLADX, FAIRX, MetWest Total Return and GIM I found out today that Morningstar has downgraded SLADX to neutral. It used to be bronze.
They removed rating from MetWest total return a while ago due to turnover of managers. Two managers are retiring this year and next (not 100% sure about dates). They still have not restored the rating.
Berkowitz will be on Wealthtrack next week. After being quiet for a very long time, it seems that he is back in the headlines a little bit. There was an article on FAIRX in Barron's this week. In the sign of the times, there were no comments on the article. Hopefully, Consuelo will ask him the following:
- Who is on his team now? Fernandez and the people that replace him have all left. Of course Pitkowsky and Trauner left when Fernandez got promoted to co-manager. Info about his team is absent from Fairholme site. A long time ago they were listed.
- What has Bruce learned from Sears and Fannie Mae preferred mistakes? I noticed that he trimmed the preferred position lately. I am assuming that all the lawsuits against US gov are all done and failed. Not sure if imperial metal is going to pan out.
- He seems to buy and sell quickly now (Intel, Commercial metal,...)?
- Not sure who the shareholder that are left are? Lots of money in FAIRX is his and his family money.
- Now that Joe is 80% of portfolio there is no downside protection as he used to carry a lot of cash in the past
So it looks like Hasenstab will be fired from running GIM. Saba is taking over. He was a darling in the 2000s and since 2010 has been terrible. At some point TPINX had a LOT of $ under management. Now it is a $4.4 bil fund. Morningstar has it rated neutral
Not sure how much QE, 0% interest rates, and rise of ETFs has contributed/magnified underperformance of active managers vs. indexes. Most active managers run mutual funds although that is changing a little bit.
I own all four funds.
High Yield Bond I used PV to get the SD. Long enough ball park time frame. 1/2008 to 9/2023 for PIMIX and OSTIX. Time period year to year. Thanks for MDHIX. I will look at it.
High Yield Bond Unlike Mr. Sherman, I assumed the OP was talking about 3 yr stddev, because OSTIX's 5.46% is close to the target 5.20%. The latter is just enough lower to make it worth looking at a fund that is at least that much "better". In contrast, OSTIX's 10 yr stddev of 4.68% is not close to the 5.20% target.
Here's another fund that beats OSTIX over 3, 5, and 10 years with 3 year std dev below 5.2%.
MDHIX (avail @$2500 min in Fidelity IRAs)
Returns (10/27/23) 3.68% 3.64% 3.96%
Risk (09/30/23)
Sharpe 0.46 0.28 0.58
Std Dev 4.24 6.26 5.13
Upside 78% 75% 78%
Downside 6% 29% 14%
Buy Sell Why: ad infinitum. People Get Ready

High Yield Bond I assume you must be looking at 10 yr SD? Because OSTIX and PIMIX have SD higher than 5.20 for 5 yr and 10 yr according to Morningstar (as of 9/30).
Below is a comparison of RSIIX, OSTIX and PIMIX per Morningstar:
3 Yrs 5 Yr 10 Yr
RSIIX
Returns (10/27/23) 6.21% 3.90% 3.88%
Risk (09/30/23)
Sharpe 1.05 0.31 0.54
Std Dev 3.63 7.01 5.23
Upside 61% 62% 65%
Downside (22%) 10% 1%
OSTIX
Returns (10/27/23) 2.91% 3.40% 3.63%
Risk (09/30/23)
Sharpe 0.31 0.27 0.57
Std Dev 5.44 5.95 4.68
Upside 89% 72% 69%
Downside 14% 27% 9%
PIMIX
Returns (10/27/23) 0.07% 2.12% 3.73%
Risk (09/30/23)
Sharpe (0.21) 0.11 0.60
Std Dev 5.77 6.18 4.67
Upside 105% 86% 91%
Downside 48% 55% 33%
Selling Like Hotcakes - PIMIX, DODIX Your comments regarding bond funds in 2022 and 2023 are spot-on.
You have a knack for reporting past performance.
I'm much more interested in future bond fund performance.
Can you tell me which bond funds or bond categories will outperform over the next 5 Yr/10 Yr?
Thanks in advance!
Selling Like Hotcakes - PIMIX, DODIX I warned about PIMIX since early 20
18 (after holding it for about 7-8 years at a huge %) when I sold it and never looked back. RCTIX is a good replacement.
But, most bond funds have done badly since early 2022 because the Fed have been raising rates. In that environment, bank loans shine...and they did (less in 2022 and a lot more in 2023).
EIFAX is my LT favorite BL but FAFRX has been shining for months. A chart of all 5 proves it. (
https://schrts.co/sszRneNS).
In fact, in 2023 EIFAX+FAFRX beat most generic stock categories such as SPY,IWM(SC),VGK(Europe),EEM while growth/QQQ beat them all easily. See YTD chart(
https://schrts.co/yKTxTKtQ)
Who said that bonds can't make money?