Howdy, Stranger!

It looks like you're new here. If you want to get involved, click one of these buttons!

In this Discussion

  • bee December 2013
  • msf December 2013
Here's a statement of the obvious: The opinions expressed here are those of the participants, not those of the Mutual Fund Observer. We cannot vouch for the accuracy or appropriateness of any of it, though we do encourage civility and good humor.

    Support MFO

  • Donate through PayPal

Fidelity Undercuts Vanguard's Target Data Funds

Comments

  • So far T Rowe Price has out distanced both Vanguard and Fidelity when it comes to performance:

    Target Date 2051+Funds:
    finance.yahoo.com/funds/lists/?mod_id=mediaquotesmutualfunds&cat=$FOCA$TL$$
  • msf
    edited December 2013
    You wouldn't know from the article, but the Fidelity funds are achieving their ER via a temporary fee waiver.

    (Actually, a tip off is that all the funds have the same ER. The funds are comprised of underlying index funds each with their own (different) ERs. So it's highly improbable that all the funds of funds would have the identical ER including acquired fund costs, unless the ER were rigged via a waiver.)

    The waivers range from 9 to 11 basis points (i.e. about 70% of the current ER), and are set to expire May 31, 2016.

    Likely you also wouldn't know about these funds from Fidelity, since they're nowhere to be found on the retail pages. It looks like they are only available to retirement plans (e.g. 401k plans). Here's Fidelity's 6 page glossy, via Union College.

    In the 90s, Fidelity started orienting its company toward gathering retirement plan assets. This is when Magellan became an index hugger (and worse), and when Fidelity clamped down on its managers. Fidelity seems to be using these index funds as part of that strategy (keeping quiet about them except to employers).

    To bee's comment/link - you won't find Fidelity Freedom Index funds listed there (even though another Fidelity employer-only series, Strategic Advisers Muliti-Manager, is there). According to Univ. of Michigan's announcement when they transitioned from Freedom Funds to Freedom Index Funds, the two sets of funds are supposed to be following similar strategies (which I assume means similar glide path). So the Freedom Index funds likely performed similarly to the Freedom funds.

    I spot checked the 2030 fund - Fidelity's index fund underperformed Fidelity's comparable actively managed fund by 55 basis points over the past three years. (The Freedom Index funds are four years old.) Haven't checked whether this is due to different glide paths, or inferior performance by the underlying index funds.
  • Reply to @msf: Fidelity seems to slice and dice...there are almost 800 flavors of funds at Fidelity listed on Yahoofinance and as you mentioned not all are listed there. I have a hard time trying to decide between vanilla and chocolate. Wish companies like Fidelity would simplify and focus more on performance...less on marketing.
Sign In or Register to comment.